Tomato Pie Cafe in Allison Park

Fresh, healthy, and delicious food!

The Tomato Pie is a gem! Fantastic food and friendly service.

A little out of the way but well worth the trip

Food was pretty good,we sat outside and enjoyed the nice weather. This establishment is cash only so come with cash in hand. We had a nice young server,but she forget our drinks 3x. We could of been in and out but we has to wait 20 min for our check. We would like to visit again soon.

Great place just opened up for the year byob

We stop by for dinner on a Saturday night, according to the waitress we were not allowed to have soda pop because the owner does not like it and refuses to sell it,the only thing available was water, ice tea and lemonade. If you want alcohol its BYOB.I thought she was kidding but she shrugged her shoulders, shook her head no ,and gave a sarcastic smile. We walked out and will never go back. From reading some of these comments the owner definitely has psychological issues. This used to be a cool place to go to.maybe he will go out of business and someone else will take over and cater to the needs of their customers.

Nice atmosphere, good food

Best pizza around!

At one time this spot was great for Italian dinners. Foods, servers and customer satisfaction has gone down hill. Ordered pizza from menu with preselected toppings. Did not get the toppings listed on menu and was told you get what we have. Not very friendly. I'll never go back.

Delicious!

Really unique, and down to earth place to dine. Don't expect elegance but rather a family patio atmosphere. His pies are great and taste home made and not processed. Btw, I don't like soda either.

Don’t miss this little gem! Food is excellent and staff are kind and efficient. Place could use an update inside, but it’s clean. I had the beans and greens. Portions are huge.

Stopped here after a PITT game, had one of the pizzas and it was delicious. Rico makes it all from scratch and grows some of the ingredients onsite, and you can taste the difference. We will be coming back for sure.

Favorite spot for dinner in the summer 🇮🇹

Loved the food. The service was spectacular. Also the young man working there, Matt Chiappa, was extremely nice, helpful, and attentive. Not to mention he is a very attractive young man.

Amazing taste

Penne pink leak is the best. Also great pizza

Great pizza with fresh ingredients from the back yard. The spinach feta pizza is the best.

It's a shame I have to give 2-stars since my wife has always raved of this place but our pick up order was very poor.Quite a wait for our order after the allotted pickup time which I don't mind, but when things pile on it becomes part of the issue. Chicken salads are small portion for the price and the chicken was cold. Like its pulled from the fridge for your order. Also got a "tomato pie pizza" that came with nothing more than cheese and tomatoes. No garlic, no oregano, no basil. Just a large flavorless tomato and cheese pizza.My wife will have to wait until I am not home to order from here again.

One of my favorite places in Lancaster! Took friends from Pittsburgh to visit here and they all agreed it was the best brunch they had ever had. From the cute atmosphere, to the delicious specialty drinks to the tremendous tomato pie, it's a must go to place!

Great local homegrown Italian spot! They grow most of their own produce right on the property. Everything feels homemade and authentic here. It's really nice to sit outside on the flower covered patio ‍

Deliciously different!

Excellent as usual plus sitting outside on April 6th is a bonus!

Phenomenal food and the outdoor seating is great. Be warned though, getting a table or getting a check is difficult.

What a peaceful and happy place to enjoy a high quality bite to eat! We sat on the screened in porch off the back of the restaurant. The pizza was so fresh and delicious. The tomatoes on the pizza tasted the way tomatoes should taste! Flavors are abounding and the beautiful garden that creates them surrounds as you enjoy your meal!

Good pizza. Small portions on other dishes. Service was slow. Restroom sink had no hot water.

Cozy and friendly atmosphere here! If you love fresh food, drop in and give this place a try. We had a fresh beer salad with goat cheese and balsamic vinaigrette along with a pizza with all fresh toppings. Delicious! Will visit again for sure! 😊

they have awesome lek pasta

We couldn't have asked for a better first experience at Tomato Pie Cafe. The pizza was absolutely amazing and the staff was equally impressive! We really enjoyed our visit and hope to be back in the near future!

One of the best

Best pizza around!

I had one of their fabulous pizzas for lunch today!

Oof

I went there with three friends and two of our kids. Owner came out and screamed at us for taking up two tables for 2 hours (we were there for an hour and a half). Six chairs could not fit around the round tables that they had outside so we needed two tables. We had the kids eat first and catch football in parking lot next to the restaurant so they could seat another table. The pizza took 45 minutes...part of the reason we were there so long...definitely not because of the atmosphere. Owner had bus boy come over and ask us to squeeze into one table. Had to ask for silverware, plates, drinks etc. He came out and screamed at us and said that he was done babysitting. And kicked a chair. We were watching our boys the whole time. Very very unprofessional...will NEVER go back! Not kid friendly. Other customers were scared. Ohh...he was screaming OUT of the kitchen window until we left. Would not recommend this place to anyone!!!

Overpriced and average food. No AC. Most kids working not attentive. broken tables. long wait times for food. no changing tables in restrooms.

Enjoyed the food. BYOB.

Everything was so good! EVERYTHING!

Last Friday, my cousin, her son (my godson) and I went to eat there. There were only 2 people waiting tables and they were busy. It took 10-15 minutes for someone to wipe off the table and take our drink and food orders. The food was really good, however I was sick until Monday and my cousin was sick until Sunday (we got the same thing, my godson was fine). We were there for almost 2 hours and all we did was eat.

Tomato Pie is a hidden gem in North Park. The food is outstanding and the prices are so reasonable. We love that it is BYOB and we can get a great pasta dish, beans and greens and the kids can get a pizza (or two). It is truly farm to table when the chef comes out and picks vegetables while you are eating.

Simple, delicious, casual, BYOB, with great outdoor seating.

The place has awsome atmosphere. The food is probably good.. but i never got a chance to know.. the place is located in a big park.. and the had no pizza sold by the slice.. and the final reason i got back in my car was the also only offer cash payment.. or an atm.. nobody wants to pay over price food and have atm fees on top.. ot was clear to me why there was no cars in there parking lot.. the could use square for credit payments... its a shame... payment for me was the deal breaker

Unique rustic restaurant. Inside or patio seating. Patio has plants, flowers, herbs which are attractive. Lunch menu has sanwiches & salads which are healthy. Waiter.was knowledgeable & attentive, price was reasonable.

Great fresh salads and pizza and entrees, relaxed outdoor seating with pretty views, byo with no corking charge.

Great little place by north park

I eat in this great restaurant many times a year! This is my favorite spot to have a bite. I go to this spot frequently. The food is very good, the team is professional and the payment is fair. I like going in this place to have a good dinner.

My Lord, this was some of the best tasting pizza I've had in awhile. My lady and I went out on a whim.to order a pizza and decided to try here since we were in North Park. She got a pasta dish and I got a simple cheese pizza. The flavor was so rich and tasty I was floored. I can't wait to try different toppings.This spot is cash only. They have an ATM on site.Highly recommended

Awesome homemade style cuisine.

We absolutely adore this little restaurant! One of the best pizzas in town! Highly recommend!!!

Great little place just outside of Northpark and an easy walk from the lakeside of the park. All of their food is great, but quite pricey. They have outdoor, indoor, and a psueodo indoor balcony seating. The place is usually packed and is only open half a year as a result. Try one of their signature pizzas coupled with a dinner salad!

Fantastic Ever Single Time! A great local gem!